While Buffalo Roamed: The Wild West History of Colorado
History of Colorado’s (Old West) frontier days, western history, wild west, with the introduction to the remaining landmarks (while the buffalo and native Americans ruled the plains).
Once gold is discovered in west Kansas Territory, the western adventurers, settlers, miners, bandits, gamblers, farmers, ranchers, city builders and politicians stopped in Denver; from there these pioneers spread like ants into an unknown wilderness that would evolve into the state of Colorado.
Hero’s and villains, trials and hangings, escapes and adventure, fortunes made and lost - murder, poetry and even song - from the initial evidence left for us...
This podcast is produced locally, high in the Rocky Mountains where this history - and these stories originated.
The show is best enjoyed by listening to the episodes in order, and while not necessary, the full wild western experience is gained in this manner - full immersion - the history (stories) are in chronological order.
Our podcast will entertain and enlighten, the listener will notice much quotation from the mid to late 1800s; think of the quotations as the guests of the show. At first the language and vocabulary of the frontiersman and women will seem awkward, trust me: YOU WILL ABSORB the cadence and character and learn some new words - it will quicken your thought (I believe that - give it a solid try and see for yourself).
The episodes together form a rounded story of frontier life. The stages of civilization of the mid 1800s also translate to California, Montana, Nevada, Oregon, Utah, Arizona, Mew Mexico, Wyoming and more. Starting from campers, gold miners, ranchers…
Colorado is wonderful example of western frontier settlement. Its relative youth helps the historian or enthusiast, as does the general gold excitement which attracted so many from all over the world. Those involved in Colorado’s settlement felt that is was quite a special event in American history, which it was, and thankfully many early arrivals wrote copious notes - there’s a mountain of first hand primary source evidence. We don’t want to lose these stories, and while Colorado history is easy to obtain and read, it’s shuffled so that the storytellers or historians who didn’t have the benefits of modern research techniques, naturally missed some details we can (and have) recover(ed) today. Combine this with the author who has first hand knowledge of the particular locations and you can't help but learn a little something along the way - we shoot for “total immersion” - or something like that!
History of Colorado’s (Old West) frontier days, western history, wild west, with the introduction to the remaining landmarks (while the buffalo and native Americans ruled the plains).
Once gold is discovered in west Kansas Territory, the western adventurers, settlers, miners, bandits, gamblers, farmers, ranchers, city builders and politicians stopped in Denver; from there these pioneers spread like ants into an unknown wilderness that would evolve into the state of Colorado.
Hero’s and villains, trials and hangings, escapes and adventure, fortunes made and lost - murder, poetry and even song - from the initial evidence left for us...
This podcast is produced locally, high in the Rocky Mountains where this history - and these stories originated.
The show is best enjoyed by listening to the episodes in order, and while not necessary, the full wild western experience is gained in this manner - full immersion - the history (stories) are in chronological order.
Our podcast will entertain and enlighten, the listener will notice much quotation from the mid to late 1800s; think of the quotations as the guests of the show. At first the language and vocabulary of the frontiersman and women will seem awkward, trust me: YOU WILL ABSORB the cadence and character and learn some new words - it will quicken your thought (I believe that - give it a solid try and see for yourself).
The episodes together form a rounded story of frontier life. The stages of civilization of the mid 1800s also translate to California, Montana, Nevada, Oregon, Utah, Arizona, Mew Mexico, Wyoming and more. Starting from campers, gold miners, ranchers…
Colorado is wonderful example of western frontier settlement. Its relative youth helps the historian or enthusiast, as does the general gold excitement which attracted so many from all over the world. Those involved in Colorado’s settlement felt that is was quite a special event in American history, which it was, and thankfully many early arrivals wrote copious notes - there’s a mountain of first hand primary source evidence. We don’t want to lose these stories, and while Colorado history is easy to obtain and read, it’s shuffled so that the storytellers or historians who didn’t have the benefits of modern research techniques, naturally missed some details we can (and have) recover(ed) today. Combine this with the author who has first hand knowledge of the particular locations and you can't help but learn a little something along the way - we shoot for “total immersion” - or something like that!
Episodes

5 days ago
E35 - Leather Forever
5 days ago
5 days ago
23 min
In this final episode of season one, we take a glimpse back, a look forward, and introduce the theater (The Haydee Stars) - the teacher (professor Owen John Goldrick) - and James Beckwourth moves to future Colorado! The cast of characters continue to grow and bloom.
WE did it!
1858 and 1859 (future) Colorado now has its colorful history in one place - digitally recorded and available to all - for as long as we keep the lights on!
Season 2? Yes... but I'm taking some time off (it's been a year and a half) need a recharge!
Thank you to all the listeners who took the time to hear these tales, this history. Without YOU, it wouldn't have been very much fun. Thank you for being there, thank you for the positive vibes and a few perfectly timed comments.
Let those who know spread our history - it's rich and interesting - let the pioneers live through our expressions.
Best wishes, and thank you again-
JB Reynolds

Jul 19, 2026
E34 - Wild West / Mild West
Jul 19, 2026
Jul 19, 2026
17 min
A short story of lawlessness in Denver City between a baker and a blacksmith is yet another illustration of the lack of law and order in the west Kansas Territory.
The settlers of western Kansas (future Colorado) are without a true government, lawlessness rules the streets.
The pioneers desperately try to organize some form of government, but end up with three poor versions: The Territory of Jefferson, the county of Arapahoe, and the miners' impromptu courts.
The need for a stable government is desperately needed (being so far away from "civilization"), and the coming year will test the pioneers when the next wave of emigrants arrive.
Murder in Denver City - not a finger is lifted to stop a argument that (needlessly) turns deadly.
Friends, thanks for listening!
Love, JB

Jun 28, 2026
E33 - Three Gates and Farewell
Jun 28, 2026
Jun 28, 2026
28 min
Today we cover three (1859) ghost towns all within 5 miles of Golden, Colorado and all invisible!
Baden, Golden Gate City and Mt. Vernon
All three towns existed at the foot of their respective mountain "gate" or "road" - nothing you might be interested in walking or driving today.
An introduction to the towns (we will hear from them later), and where they are, and how you can see them today!
Thank you for coming!

Jun 21, 2026
SE7 - "Truth": Edgar Vanover Hanging Appendix
Jun 21, 2026
Jun 21, 2026
16 min
Just a short episode entered as a supplement to episode 32 (Disturbed: Golden City 1859.)
Three newspaper articles reporting on the summary hanging of Edgar Vanover (by the townspeople of Golden City - September, 5 1859).
First from the September 10, 1859 issue of the Rocky Mountain News
Second, from the September 17, 1859 issue of the Rocky Mountain News
Lastly, from the October 5, 1922 issue of the Colorado Transcript
These articles (combined) offer the best details on this tragic event, the summary hanging of a man who committed no actual crime deserving of that drastic resolution.
Edgar Vanover, Golden City, Summary Justice, Kansas Territory

Jun 14, 2026
E32 - Disturbance: Golden City, 1859
Jun 14, 2026
Jun 14, 2026
22 min
Today we add Golden City to the West Kansas Territory (future Colorado) - July of 1859.
The Boston Company arrives in Golden on June 12, after helping Thomas Gibson with that EXTRA (from episode 13) - a printing job for the Rocky Mountain News. The group land in Golden (nameless at the time) and finds the location perfect for a supply town.
First, a Quick Look at Golden's interesting geology, then we dive into Parfet Park...
Why you ask?
Parfet Park (10th street and Washington Ave.) was the location of the first (permanent) structure in Golden, built by members of The Boston Company.
Golden City is platted in Clear Creek Valley, the new town grows rapidly, but, it becomes evident that a major oversight has been committed, there's neither law, nor a lawman - no court, no judge, no lawyers, no jail!
- This "system" is tested in September of 1859 -
A drunken local businessman gets a little "too" wild for the townspeople. A "desperado" he is later labeled...
Mr. Vanover, in his intoxicated condition, made some threats, shot his revolver at some kitchenware - he yelled a lot, and he was (supposedly) a wanted man (for what crimes nobody knew) - but he never touched anybody - BUT, he didn't hurt anyone.
Edgar's threats of violence alarmed the townsfolk, and by the afternoon, after chasing him into a nearby cabin, his fate was "calmly" discussed by the crowd. By the "town."
The two options: Banishment or execution.
A vote ensued, and banishment was NOT the winner!
Moments later, Edgar Vanover was hanging dead; his body attached to a meat gallows by the neck.
After the lynching, he was buried in the vagrant section of the town cemetery (Cemetery Hill, now Goldco Circle between first fifth streets) - he's still there.
Vanover is later honored by the town of Golden... In 2006, Vanover Park was dedicated - but you won't find a historical marker there telling THIS story...
Summary justice in the wild, wild, West.
Kansas Territory, 1859

May 31, 2026
E31 - No Tomorrow: Deadman Gulch Gunnison
May 31, 2026
May 31, 2026
31 min
Deadman’s Gulch, Gunnison / Almont ColoradoUte Massacre, Gunnison, Taylor Reservoir, Cement Creek, Spring Creek, East River, Continental Divide, Lost Dead are Found
This episode we revisit the Ute ambush and murder of 7 men, as well as their animals - in August of 1859 - But why?
New evidence suggests the location of the fateful battle AND the resting place of the miners.
The location was discovered immediately (in 1859), but bad communication and labeling of various water courses kept the bodies of seven men hidden, decomposing quietly in the sunny gulch -
In 1860, a prospecting party buried the remains, but again misidentified the location, naming the headwaters of the Rio Grande (another time, the location is printed as being at the headwaters of the Colorado - wrong again).
Nobody knew the strangers, they were deep in Ute country, and for whatever reason, their journey ended in what is now known as Deadman's Gulch, in the Gunnison National Forest, just northeast of Almont - between the Cement Mountains.
I hike the trail and explain what happened here in 1859, and what I saw last week on the trail.
Also, we look at how the legend changed, and was eventually adopted by the Leadville Miners of the 1870s and 1880s.
Full show
Love,
JB

May 21, 2026
SE6 - The Redwoods of Colorado
May 21, 2026
May 21, 2026
7 min
Redwoods in Colorado?
What if the pine trees and deep snow of the Colorado Rockies are sitting right on top of an ancient, tropical jungle?
35 million years ago, the heart of Colorado's South Park basin and the Florissant Valley looked more like Central America than the high altitude country we know today. Giant, 150 foot tall redwoods choked the humid valleys, while rhinoceros sized "thunder beasts" crashed through the underbrush.
But these massive trees carried a strange evolutionary secret from a past life in the ice free high Arctic - and their mountain paradise was about to meet a violent, volcanic end.
In this short episode, we chart the epic 65 million year-old Odyssey of the Redwood family tree. We explore their massive migration down the continent, the catastrophic volcanic mud flows that trapped them in stone, and the mind blowing 1943 plot twist that proved a branch of this prehistoric forest never actually went extinct.
In this episode, you'll discover:
The Backyard Monster - How the Guffey Volcanic Complex created a world class fossil goldmine.
The Arctic Secret: Why an ancient Colorado redwoods drop their needles in the winter time, unlike California redwoods.
The Botanical Time capsule: How the catastrophic mud flows of Lake Florissant perfectly sealed away a prehistoric world.
Hiding in Plain Sight: The jaw-dropping 1943 "rediscover" of China's living "dinosaur" tree.
Hit play and travel back 35 million years into Colorado's hidden tropical past!

May 17, 2026
E30 - Fair Play, Breckenridge and Buckskin
May 17, 2026
May 17, 2026
25 min
Buckskin Joe, Fair Play, Tarry All, Breckenridge, Mosquito Pass, South Park and Florissant (one time home to a redwood forest) -
Kansas and Utah Territories 1859; Fair Play begins, Joe Higgenbotham or Higgenboittom leads a group of prospectors up into high mountains above Fair Play - Thomas Breckenridge gets a town named for him (...and a pass). Fort Mary B. Mosquito Pass (unnamed is seen), California Gulch (future Leadville) is prospected. Buckskin Joe, an ancient dumpster, petrified wood, redwood forest of Colorado, a trick to get a post office established on the western slope of future Colorado!
South Park's ancient gold location?
Florissant Fossil Beds National Monument and why you should visit.
Hope you enjoy-
JB







